Social Media MegaTrends : Socio-Economic Impact

by Hareesh Tibrewala on Sunday, August 22nd, 2010

Once upon a time, almost a century back, human occupation was mostly “transformational” in nature. Taking raw material and converting into finished goods. Be it a carpenter at work or be it a worker in a factory or perhaps a farmer engaged in agriculture, a majority of the work force was engaged in the business of transformation.

A few decades later, there was shift in the workforce occupation. From transformation workers we became transaction workers. Ringing up bills at the cash counter, an accountant, a truck driver, an office clerk….all these are examples of a transaction driven workforce (basically doing tasks that are rule based and repetitive in nature).

Now we see another shift taking place i.e. from a transaction-active workforce to an interaction-active workforce. An insurance agent, a nurse, a retail salesman, they are all interaction-workers. Interaction requires ability to use ones experience in a given situation. There are a set of experiences and there a set of situations. And a successful interaction worker is the one who is able to respond to a situation by correctly leveraging his experience. He needs to make complex interactions requiring high level of judgement.

If the world GDP, once upon a time was mainly contributed by transformation workforce, today it is mainly contributed by Interaction workforce. Tasks that were transformational in nature or transactional in nature are gradually being taken over by machines. And tasks that are interactive in nature … here is where Social Media is playing the role of an enabler.

Whether Social Media is going to drive the interaction-economy or whether interaction-economy will spur faster growth of social media…either ways it is mutually beneficial relationship.

22.08.2010 General, Hareesh, Mega Trends, Social Media Mega Trends, social media View Comments

Strategising for Social Media : The Three Circles of Success

by Hareesh Tibrewala on Wednesday, April 21st, 2010

Are you struggling to grow your Facebook Fans ? Or not getting enough quality followers on Twitter? Do a Google search and you will find zillions of articles telling you “10 ways to increase your Facebook Fans” and “5 Tips to Getting more Twitter Followers”. And perhaps following some of these tips may actually help to get some numbers.  However as Social Media matures,  we will see a shift happen from “activity” based thinking to building a “strategic” approach to finding and more importantly retaining Followers and Fans.

I like to the think of a Social Media communication  strategies in terms of 3 concentric circles. Think of the brand as being at the centre.

  • Circle (A) is the circle of fans (say on Facebook)  who are already connected to the brand
  • Circle (B) is the circle of friends, of all those fans who are already connected to the brand
  • And Circle (C) is “rest of the world”

Any Social Media strategy has to think in terms of what to communicate to each of these 3 circles and how to expand A (that is the end objective)

Let us look at circle A.  If you, as a brand, have a  1000 fans on your fan page, you have 1000 people who are willing to receive information from you. How do you keep them engaged?  How do you ensure that they continue receiving your feed? There is always a possibility that a person is your fan but has turned off receiving your feed…..hence you continue to see him in your fan count but he is actually not there.

These are early days, and right now people are going to be joining all  kinds of fan pages, mostly out of curiosity and partly on account  of some tempting promotion or give-away. But as dust settles, consumers will  be more discerning . A consumer does not  want to be scrolling through 10 pages of FB updates on a daily basis. Primarily he want to receive updates from his friends . He wants to know what is happening in their lives…that is his primary reason to be on Facebook. At the same time he is  willing to allow a few brands to send him messages. Hence very soon brands will need to compete for attention from their fans.

In order to ensure that your fan is willing to receive your feed, it is important for you  to occupy some portion of your  fans (consumers) life.  In his daily life, you need to mean something to him. Hence start by identify what part of his life (or his needs) can you fulfil. And this thinking will need to be “outside-in” and not “inside-out”. Do not think “What do I make and how can I get my fan to buy it “. Rather, think: What does my TG (target group) really look for in their day-to-day lives and what part of their needs can I fulfil (which also in some way connects to what my brand stands for). E.g if you are manufacturer of soaps, you can fulfil the need of a beautician in your consumers life. If you are are an insurance company, you can fulfil the need of a financial planner…..and so on. Once you identify what part of your consumers life you can own (and mind you “go thin”. Don’t try to be everything to your consumer. Try to be something very specific…. that will give you the edge), engage your consumer around that.

Note, the word is “engage” not “sell”. While communicating to your fans by way of Facebook updates, follow the 80:20 ratio. 80% of the communication should be about fulfilling the consumers needs, not about promoting the brand.  If as brand, 80% of the time you talk to consumer about something  meets his needs, then maybe 20% time he will be willing to listen to your marketing communication.

This is how you work on engaging circle A and more importantly ensuring that the consumer remains with you and does not hide your updates from his Facebook feed. These are early days and brands that are able to occupy a part of the consumers Facebook timeline, will find it easy to leverage the asset base.

Circle B is the circle of all those people who are friends of  those people who are already your fans. If you have 1000 fans, and each of these fans is connected to an average of 300 people, then circle  B comprises of 300,000 people. And these 300,000 people are most likely the kind of people that you as a brand are looking for. E.g. If you were a medical brand and all my fans are doctors, then who are their friends likely to be ? Obviously more doctors…and these are exactly the kind of guys you are looking for. Hence the key focus for any social media practitioner should be to find ways to convert people from circle B to circle A.

And how does that happen ?  Via people in circle  A.  People in circle A need to be “motivated” to tell their friends in circle B, to join the fan page of your brand. And how does this “motivation” manifest itself :

  • Provide shareable content: As someone said “I will not tell my friends about your brand because I like your brand, I will tell them because I like my friends”. So think, what is it that your fans will find worthy of sharing.  A text posting in not shareable on Facebook. Hence good content supported by visual communication (images, videos) will make the content shareable.
  • Polls, quizzes, photo tagging, group activities are other methods of reaching out to your fans’ friends
  • Facebook applications : This is one of the most powerful tools to leverage circle A to reach out the circle B. Application should be designed in such a manner that is involves your fans getting their friends to participate via the application. Hopefully while participating, lot of them may get motivated  join your fan page.

And then we come to circle C. This is the rest of the 400 million Facebook users (less people in circle A and circle B) reside. This is the biggest circle in terms of size but also one prone to high wastage in terms of rewards-to-efforts.  Ways to reach out to this circle would be by way of

  • Participation on relevant Facebook forums and becoming a part of that community
  • Creating virals that get forwarded and talked about
  • Creating events and contests that can spread by word-out-mouth
  • Advertising on Facebook. These are early days and cost of fan acquisition on Facebook is still affordable

A successful growth strategy has to able to create a ripple effect that percolates from Circle A to B and then to C

In my opinion one should focus one’s efforts as  follows

  • Initially build  Circle A : Keep them engaged and involved. Ensure they don’t turn off the update feed that you send them. Try to become an important part of their lives
  • Then get on to Circle B : This is the most relevant TG for a brand and perhaps the easiest the crack.
  • And finally look at  Circle C : As a brand we need them but then this is like finding needles in a haystack. Facebook advertising or viral applications could act as a magnet to pull out the needles in the haystack.

What  is your opinion ?

21.04.2010 Hareesh, facebook, social media View Comments

The Shashi Tharoor and IPL saga: Social Media Lessons

by sanjay on Monday, April 19th, 2010

If voting was restricted to Twitter alone, Shashi Tharoor could have been elected Prime Minister of India! Sadly for Tharoor, it isn’t, and there is life beyond.

Without a doubt, Shashi Tharoor has done more for brand Twitter in India than anybody else! Common citizens, who are far away from using Twitter, also recognize the word Twitter, thanks to Tharoor, and the news he made, with his cattle-class and such tweets!

But the same medium that made him famous, could well have spelled Tharoor’s undoing. And which is where, there are Social Media lessons to learn, for the rest of us. But I am jumping to the conclusion. Let me cut back to the beginning first.

So the Tharoor – Sunanda Pushkar –  Lalit Modi – IPL saga has been enough in the news, for me to repeat the gory details. And this piece is not about who was right and who was wrong, but more about Shashi Tharoor, and the Social Media mistakes he made.

The genesis of his mistakes though, can be understood, if we understand his personality. And M J Akbar does a great job of describing this in his Sunday piece in the Times of India. Couples of key facts pointed out by Akbar are that Tharoor did not leave his high profile and high pay UN assignment to join Indian politics, rather he left it to try and get the top job at the UN. And that for Tharoor, half limelight is better than no limelight! Also that Bush considered him to be immature.

In all of these statements lie perhaps, the explanations for Tharoor shooting off his mouth every now and then, and for his landing into a mess now, which Akbar puts as “writhing between a mistake and misfortune”.

Tharoor through his wild and popular run as the favorite Indian Twitter celebrity account, made an art of creating 140 character copy. Tweets that would be cheered by Indian Twitterati, tweets that would get huge RTs, and which as a consequence, generated huge Twitter following, and a cheering squad, which was happy to get a ‘cool and handsome MP who was tongue-in-cheek, and had a great sense of humor too, and who was so different from the boring Indian politicians of the day’! Tharoor looking for that half limelight could have not asked for more. To repeat the first sentence of this post, he had reached a position where if an election was based solely on Twitter votes, he had reached a position where he would win hands-down!

But the fact was that, Tharoor was just a great copywriter and made tweets interesting. He was not really that cool as a person, and he was not that far from the other politicians he would ridicule so often, in terms of his integrity.

And Santosh Desai, in his column again in the Times of India, explains how Tharoor’s slick language and style got him into more trouble than good, and how in this particular case, it landed him into quick sand. When style comes without adequate substance, such slips happen. And Tharoor slipped, ultimately resulting in loss of face, and an ignominious resignation from the ministry.

As Santosh Desai points out, and I have seen in person, in the twitter stream, and in the Tharoor support forums that have sprung up, Tharoor will still remain a favorite on Twitter. But his political future is another issue.

So what is the key Social Media lesson here?

The one and most important fact that this episode brings to the fore, is that on Social Media, you cannot pretend to be someone you are not. Or in other words, it is not just about words you use, but that you really have to ‘be it’. Take into contrast, another celebrity, Anand Mahindra. In fact, there has been a decent compilation of Anand Mahindra’s Twitter efforts, and how effectively he has used the medium. Now Anand Mahindra asks questions, admits he does not know it all, converses genuinely, and helps where he can. In short, he comes out as a regular human being, even if he is not one another common man. On the other hand, Tharoor came out looking larger than life, which unfortunately he was not!

And this is the last thing you do on Social Media. Social Media in general and Twitter in particular, is very public space. It amplifies conversations, and you create a Social Media brand positioning / reputation for yourself. If this is very different from who you really are, the pretense cannot be kept up for too long. Because Social Media has its own way of circling back, and haunting you, for your inconsistencies.

Social Media is about being honest to yourself, it is about transparency, and it is about being fair to your fans and followers.

As someone pointed out, best practices on use of Social Media are yet to emerge. But in the early days as we are, these are some early lessons to pick.

In lighter vein, Shashi Tharoor could attempt another first on Twitter, if he wants. If he chooses to resign from Twitter as well, he could be the first one to auction off his 700-odd-thousand follower account?!

19.04.2010 General, Sanjay, india, learning, social media View Comments

Where did ONE YEAR go? 1st Anniversary letter to our clients!

by sanjay on Monday, April 5th, 2010

Dear Customer,
The new Financial Year has started. But for us at Social Wavelength, it also coincides with our birthday. We got started in early April, 2009. And wow.. the year has zipped by!

Social Media is exciting. And being in the thick of things, as a Social Media agency, we have had year long excitement! And it promises not to stop, and in fact, it only gets  zippier.

So here are some highlights of the year that went by:

  1. The first two months were, well, the first two months! The first two young men I decided to employ left me in 1 day and 2 days respectively.. lol. Then I managed to get a person whom I had worked with earlier, to get started with us. At least she would not run away. Its another thing that she was just not cut out for Social Media, and we had to part few months later!
  2. There was still the issue of getting a first client. The only way to do it, was to catch a friend. And get his business. Which is what I did with Kartik Shah. And Skyscape Inc., USA remains a client. In the interim, they got bought over! Maybe we brought them good luck!!
  3. How I got my first partner, in this business, is another story. But suffice it to say, that few coffees, few chats, and meeting of the minds, made this happen. An unlikely combination of a 23 year old Engineer, into his first job after engineering, quitting that job, to become an entrepreneur, by joining a 40-something (yes, 40-something is good enough; don’t ask for precise numbers here!) gray haired veteran of sorts, to help the world figure their way around Social Media! Welcome aboard, Mihir Karkare!
  4. I did not realize this first. But it sank in soon enough that we were getting into the larger framework of the advertising world! And while I was comfortable about my business understanding, my knowledge on the Internet and Social Media space, but advertising industry was a different world! There was just so much to unlearn and many new things to learn. That khakhis and shirt can often be considered as being overdressed, and that a minimum of one f*** in a sentence was mandatory, were amongst the easier things to learn. Long pre-sales cycles, longer approval cycles, and longest payment cycles were harder to figure out!!
  5. I learned that what we were preaching actually works! Yes, Social Media works for Social Media business. Doing no specific business development effort, but by being active on offline and online social media (offline social media = your personal network) generated leads, and then by providing reasonable thought leadership, this converted to business. Does this sound like what I talked to you, when I asked for your business? Well, it worked for me anyway!!
  6. October 1 is the birthday of my friend. This happened to be the momentous day when that friend – also my partner at Homeindia.com – came on board at Social Wavelength as a partner. Bringing all of his bald pate, a symbol of his wisdom and capabilities, with him, and we were now more than ready to take on the world! Welcome, Hareesh Tibrewala. Now we kick ass.. !
  7. They called us Mr. Keynote. Seeing a virtual deja vu of 1997-98 when we were called to speak all over the place, about the Internet, we now start receiving invitations to talk about Social Media. Hareesh and I need to ration the time we can give for such outings, as “we have to take care of your business too”!
  8. We have managed simply. We have limited resources which we deployed well. We have spartan premises. We do not have a pool table. We do not have guitars or any other musical instruments. We serve chai or coffee, but there too, many prefer to go down, smoke and grab a cutting from the guy downstairs. But we have a lot of enthusiasm. We have a great team, who always have fun, who have a smile on their faces, no matter what the clock reads. That’s all we need to go to the next leap now.

But all this has happened, thanks to you, dear customer. You reposed your faith in us. You are a leader to embrace this new medium so early. And most importantly – you signed our cheques :)

The one year is a milestone for sure. But we know we have many more to come. And we look to have you with us on this journey.

Meanwhile let’s do a beer together. Whenever you are free. Tell us. It will be on us (well ultimately, you pay for it!!).

Very warm regards – Sanjay Mehta

05.04.2010 General, Sanjay, social media View Comments

Social Media Mega Trends : The Power of Social Networking Sites and the Cell Phone

by Hareesh Tibrewala on Thursday, March 18th, 2010

Internet  came to town a decade ago and change our lives forever. Not only did it change the way we did business but it changed the way we lived life. Email became our primary communication tool and web URL became the primary way to disseminate information. It was OK if you did not have a physical office address but is was not OK if your business card did not carry a URL.

Web 2.0 is once again re-defining our lives. It promises to be bigger and have a more significant impact on us than Web 1.0. If Web1.0 was driven largely by Internet connectivity and PCs, Web 2.0 will be driven by the mobile telephony and Social Networking Sites( SNS).

To give an example of the power of this lethal combination of SNS and mobile phone savour the following examples

  • Imagine you area at a conference where there are another 100 delegates  like yourself. May be there are some people you know, but there is a larger number of people you don’t know. You pull out your cell phone, take up a position at a vantage point and take a picture of the audience.  Your cell phone software very quickly connects to servers to leading SNS sites, does  image mapping , and in just about no time, the picture reappears on your cell phone, except that this time it has been tagged by names of the all the people in the audience with their designations and company names. You click on a name, and that persons profile is right there before you. Now you the faces that you need to catch up with during the tea break!

Each one of us are now fully “identifiable” at any point of time. It is almost like having a name tag pinned to your Tshirt pocket at all times. Even if one wants to remain anonymous, this combination of a cell phone + SNS sites, ensures that there is no place to hide….not anymore

Let us look at another example of how this cell phone +SNS combination is going to transform our decision making process

  • Imagine I am tourist who has come to Mumbai from Delhi. Here I am, at the Hanging Garden, enjoying the sight of Chowpatty. Now I wish to proceed for lunch. Once a time I would need to depend on a tourist guide book or the taxiwalla to guide me.  Now, no more!  I flash my cell phone, switch on the camera and hold it against a view of the Chowpatty landscape. I click a button asking for a listing of restaurants. Promptly all restaurants that are  in focus in  the camera appear tagged on the camera. Now I know that there is Pizza Hut and a Rajdhani and a Copper Chimney in my view. I click on a particular restaurant and I can see the menu card and the price list. I click on yet another button and I can see recommendations.  Best of all, I can specifically see recommendations made by people who are known to me.  Technology needs to connect the restaurant website to the website that carries recommendations to my Facebook page…and I can see exactly which of my friends have made what recommendations for a particular restaurant.  So then who decides where I eat ? No longer the tourist guide book and no longer the taxiwalla. It is my friends who are helping me decide where I eat.

18.03.2010 social media View Comments

Social Media Strategies for Brands with High Consumer Touch Points

by sanjay on Sunday, February 28th, 2010

A lot of brands have high consumer touch points. Footfalls, if you please. Literal footfalls, like in stores. Or airlines. Or cinema houses. Coffee shops. Etc, etc.
Or virtual footfalls, like in a popular web site.
Or remote footfalls like in television channels, with high viewer base.

When such brands go on to Social Media, as they embrace the new platforms like Facebook or Twitter, they do start from zero. Usually, the approach remains restricted to the Social Media space, and fan base is attempted to be built organically, or through other means, but by staying in the Social Media space, and creating interesting strategies, or spending money there itself.

Why not integrate the physical touch points, and convert them to be your fans?? Would that not accelerate the growth of fans on Facebook? How about converting those Footfalls to become your Fans?!

Here is a presentation that I made to the Social Media Club in Mumbai, India, about this proposition:

Turning Footfalls into Fans,and Fans to Footfalls: Social Media Lessons for brands with large consumer touch points

In case you are unable to view the Slideshare presentation embedded above, in your browser, then you can view the same here.

The interesting element to note is the second part of the story, viz. getting those Facebook fans, back into the stores. That is often forgotten or left to chance. However very little business is actually done on those Facebook pages. The money to be earned is in the stores, and not on Facebook.

The key element is to get the fan from Facebook, back into the stores, spending money. And which is all about converting the Fans back to being Footfalls!

What do you think about this? Do you see a closer integration of messaging in the offline space, and the Social Media space, for a brand? I’d love to read your views. Please share them as comments here!

28.02.2010 Monetization, Sanjay, advertising, campaign, facebook, marketing, retail, social media, twitter View Comments

How Gary Vaynerchuck got 800,000 twitter followers (Why your brand should help build and empower communities)

by mihir on Sunday, February 14th, 2010

Social Media has been a great enabler for communities. It has allowed people with similar passions to share their thoughts and ideas with each other. This much, of course, we know.

For a brand, these shared passions and the communities formed around them provide an excellent opportunity. By facilitating these communities and the exchange of ideas within them, brands stand to gain a lot. This is being recognized in various sectors – many of which one would not expect to be new-media savvy.

Interested in solder, epoxy flux or metal oxides? Indium Corporation has a host of blogs talking about these very topics. People from across the industry – from within Indium corp. and from without now have a go-to place for conversation about these topics and many more.

Schneider Electric ran a petition campaign to raise awareness about the contribution of building (especially high-rises) to global warming. For a certain group of people, this particular topic is extremely important, and the petition reached its goal of having 500 people signing up for it. This included text and video petitions. Schneider, of course, has a building automation solution which can help reduce the adverse impact which buildings have on the environment – so raising awareness served a direct goal

Fair Enough. Brands are providing platforms on which likeminded people, passionate about a particular topic can gather. But how is it actually helping the brand? In many cases, the benefits are quite direct!

Take for example Gary Vaynerchuck. The community he addresses is that of wine drinkers. Not exactly a small niche (*hiccup*) – a large number of people are extremely passionate about wines. Gary understood this (his family owned a wine shop) and he utilized Social Media tools – largely online video – to help the community come together. Gary started Wine Library TV – a video blog – in 2006 and it recently crossed its 800th episode. And what has Gary achieved? Apart from being a Social Media superstar it has propelled his wine business to a completely new level. Interestingly, viewers of the video blog (called ‘Vayniacs’) have created the first ever community wine – the Vayniac Cabernet.

What are the numbers like, for Gary? He has over 80,000 viewers on WLT every day, over 847,000 twitter followers and over 24,000 Facebook fans. Essentially, what Gary did, was that he acted as a focal point around which a community could congregate.

Here’s one of Wine Library TV’s popular episodes:

This is a huge opportunity for companies and brands to tap. If your product or brand is built around an idea which people care deeply about, (or if your target audience cares deeply about anything in particular) give these people a platform. Allow them to assemble there, communicate with each other, and share. Be a part of their conversation. Don’t be pushy about your agenda – people will appreciate the fact that this platform is ‘powered by’ you. What is the idea which Gary speaks about, for example? That together, his audience and he are changing the wine world!

What platform can you provide to your audience? What do you think about this whole platform thing anyway? Let us know, in the comments.

14.02.2010 social media View Comments

Social Media in India: Seven Findings from 2009, Seven Wishes for 2010

by sanjay on Sunday, January 10th, 2010

Over the last 7 months of 2009, we have been actively participating in the Social Media industry in India, interacting with large number of clients, and that experience of 7 months has translated into this summary of 7 findings from 2009, and 7 wishes that we have for the industry, for 2010.

Our early client (or even agency) interactions were about a concept sale, for Social Media. And there was an incredulous feel as to what were we doing in their conference room, talking about Facebook and such kids’ stuff!

We’ve traversed a long distance since those days.

Of course, it is still early days for Social Media in India, but in a lot of ways, things have moved ahead:

  1. Increasingly now, people know that Social Media needs to be a part of their marketing mix, if not yet, a part of their business processes itself. For those who understand the space, they will appreciate this difference. Perhaps by the time we review the space in end 2010, we may see that Social Media has also become a part of the company’s business processes!
  2. We do not need to struggle to explain our business. A simple term like “Social Media Agency” is understood by most now. Though we are not strictly a Social Media Agency, we are close to that, and if a simple phrase can generate a close enough recognition, we are okay to let things be there.
  3. In case of a few of our clients, we had picked up their abandoned early efforts of a Facebook page, for others we had started fresh ones. Suffice to say that ALL of those clients realize now that the Facebook page, the Twitter account, the blog, the YouTube channel etc. are their digital assets and  that they will not abandon these creations any more. Whether we manage these for them or they choose to do it themselves, their Social Media activities are here to stay. Note that the word “ROI” did not even come up in this! So there!!
  4. In the early days, it was easy to get an acceptance to create a Facebook page or a blog or a Twitter account. From a hygiene factor, these were good to have. Things have changed here as well. While we still get many prospects who want to do Facebook and Twitter for the hygiene factor, there are others who have started seeing beyond. We have clients who have integrated Social Media very well with their offline marketing and others who are now asking for stand-alone Social Media strategies, with specific focus. There are few who have realized, that Facebook could be their new Email, in terms of having a regular and direct reach to their customers.
  5. It took a while to get clients to accept our retainer fees. A few commented that our monthly fees were more than their annual PR budgets. Valid point, but  an apples vs oranges comparison really. What did that annual PR budget get them? A few print releases / mentions in the papers? With large reach, potentially, but with a blink-and-miss probability and also the life of just that one day for the effort? Whereas, the Social Media activities were an ongoing effort, an all-day activity done for them every day, and which resulted in strong digital assets being established for them, which were here to stay! It needed a different kind of dedicated effort, and produced a different kind of result as well. Thankfully, from clients who are in the know, our fees seem more acceptable and understood now.
  6. We are very pleased to see a big shift from our agency friends. I mean, the advertising, PR and media buying agency partners. We have seen hesitation, threat, doubt and fear in the early days, but we are now seeing an increasing confidence in the Social Media space, from many. They have become open to new ideas, and to some extent, they are putting these up to clients, and many are getting through as well. This is going to be the most exciting part of 2010, I believe.
  7. We are also happy to see companies looking at Social Media Monitoring as a part of the Social Media activities. Although still a pariah amongst all of the Social Media methods (in India), a few companies have started seeing the potential of “listening” and we are seeing this number go up. Businesses which are more sensitive to customer feedback, are especially concerned about managing their online reputations, and monitoring becomes an integral component here.

Having said all this, what we would really like to see change some more, are things like:

  1. More clients seeing the relevance and importance of Social Media and at least beginning with the reference of the Social Media contact points on their collaterals, their website, their email signature files etc.
  2. That clients realize that the challenge for the 0-1000 journey (the first 1000 Facebook fans or Twitter followers, say) is not trivial, and requires their participation. If that means that the client needs to put the Social Media icons and links on their website, on their TV commercial and press advertisements, send out emails to intimate their stakeholders, or whatever else that is required. Same needs to be done! Once a certain threshold level is reached, then the viral aspect kicks in, thanks to content and engagement activities.
  3. While we are seeing a few, we hope to see many more of our clients open up to fresh new ideas for Social Media activation, which are in addition to the simple Facebook page, Twitter account, blog and YouTube channel. An activity conceived for and within Social Media itself, and which can bring together a large base of their Target Group. Something of this nature needs a conviction and a larger commitment in terms of time and resources, but the payback is larger, as it breaks the clutter and stands out. It needs bold first mover types to grab such opportunities, and we look forward to seeing more of those, amongst our clients!
  4. We are also hoping for more buy-in from our advertising agency partners, to in turn have the conviction to present and sell to their clients, some of these new ideas. They will stand to win awards and we will be happy to stand next to them and get some reflected shine on us too, in the process. We know we have materials that can win awards for them, but we need their conviction to move it ahead!
  5. We hope this year, Mouthshut.com and others in the league are able to put better technology in place, to separate the genuine reviews and feedback, from the fraud postings. While the fraud posts impact brands in the near future, in the long run, it hurts the credibility of sites like mouthshut.com, and make them less trustworthy!
  6. We don’t really want this to happen to anyone. But it may still happen. A brand-damaging story that starts from Social Media and hits the mainstream media all over, and causes damage to the brand. Much like the Domino’s case in the US, or even akin to the Shashi Tharoor twitter escapades. Because such damage to one brand will open the eyes of all the other brands, that Social Media cannot be taken lightly. Even if a brand does not participate in outreach activities, they need to maintain a watch, and monitor the space, to identify potential PR crisis and plug them, before they go out of control.
  7. Finally, we wish for clients to have realistic expectations. No, we do not oversell. At times, the client himself feels a huge surge of enthusiasm about Social Media. Which is perfectly fine, and good, in fact. However if this enthusiasm translates to an over expectation of results, that is tough to manage. The process of growth in Social Media is slow. Especially if done organically. Which is how most Social Media strategies are happening. Done right, the process can be made as efficient as possible. However, benchmarking with the television reach or looking for tens of thousands of fans and followers in double quick time, are all expectations that are bound to fail. A quick look at what other brands have managed, especially in their own segments, and then seeing how good or bad their own Social Media performance is, will be a good starting point to understand the positioning.

The above mentioned experiences are based across a variety of businesses, as from the outset itself, we saw clients from diverse verticals. From chemical engineering companies targeting B2B clients to television channels with millions of viewers, to electrical equipment manufacturers, software companies, hospitals, doctors, electronic device manufacturing companies, educational institutions, etc. We have seen, since then, that the prediction that within 2 to 3 years, everybody will be using Social Media is well on its way to coming true. It’s ahead of schedule actually!

All in all, it is exciting space. We are looking forward to working with many clients through 2010, and we will certainly hope to make a mark with few of our Social Media winning strategies, in course of the year. Watch this space J

10.01.2010 General, Sanjay, india, learning, social media View Comments

Social Media Monitoring: From Discovery to Mastery

by sanjay on Friday, January 1st, 2010

There are still many out there who do not understand or appreciate the concept of Social Media Monitoring. For their benefit, just a quick introduction to the idea first.

Conversations are happening on Social Media.

A blog that talks about say, telecom issues.


Comments on that blog, from various people, about the blog, but more pertinently, about their preferences or prejudices, amongst brands, for example.

Or a discussion on a message board, about hosting service providers.

And several posts to the thread, indicating active participation, besides the much larger number, who just look and go away.

Or consider a Twitter stream about Digital Cameras:

Any such discussion can significantly impact your brand, your sales. Say, by driving away customers, on account of some negative conversations, or pushing business to your competitors on account of some flattering postings in their favor, etc.

In order that these events do not catch you by surprise, you are better off to do what is referred to as “Social Media Monitoring”. That process where you keep track of the social media conversations, related to your business. Typically done with a mix of software tools and some manual data clean up, this activity is emerging as an acknowledged and regular business process for many companies now.

And now that many companies are getting into such Social Media Monitoring efforts, we see behavior and response from people, based on their stage of evolution with Social Media monitoring. And what are some of these stages, then?

    1. The discovery stage: typically from a company (or person) that has just started doing Social Media Monitoring. There is huge fascination usually, in discovering a host of mentions of their brand in Social Media. It’s almost incredible to them. Most of them did not imagine that people could be so animatedly talking about their brand. Here, the brands do not particularly go about investigating the details of what context the conversations are happening in. The discovery itself is the reward, at this point. That they are in the conversation horizon of people is a reason to feel satisfied.
    2. The first stage of investigation: this is when the company goes beyond the fascination of discovery and probes a little deeper into the nature of conversation. And this is usually followed by a few rude shocks. When it is found that many of the conversations are critical about the brand. Yes, people share good experiences with fewer people, but bad customer experiences are broadcast to many. Also that, most people who “write” into the social media space have a kind of ‘activist’ profile. And they pick up the smallest of your mistakes and amplify the same via Social Media channels. This is when companies often get upset, ask for opinions about how to “shut these guys up”, or “is there a legal recourse to stop such postings”, etc.
    3. The stage of understanding: here is where now, the company really gets serious about looking at the data that is coming out, and converting it into actionable pieces. Conversations can be about a variety of things related to a company’s brand. From quality issues, to customer service, to price, to product details, to wish-list for new services, to competitor comparison etc. Each of these needs a different handling, perhaps from different people in an organization. So now is the stage when a company starts tagging the conversations and distributing these to the right teams and people, and also starts figuring out a response mechanism, which is consistent across the organization, because finally, to the outside world, it is that “one company” only.
    4. The final stage (as of now – this space is changing!): this is when the company has now got a real good picture of the social media conversations and their impact. That many a times, the mention of their brand is inconsequential and needs to be ignored. Sometimes there is a negative mention, but it is on account of some personal reasons and can be settled offline. Or that there is conversation that they are quite familiar with, and in fact, stems out of their own press releases, for example. But then to pick those few, which are from the real ‘influencers in the space’ and which give them new and very relevant information, and which they need to act upon, is the ultimate objective. This is the “smart” way of monitoring social media, and putting it to use. It takes a lot of effort to separate the wheat from the chaff, but this is indeed, the real thing.

I am sure, there will be even more sophistication that is evolving, but the above stages largely capture the experiences of most companies, currently dabbling into the space of Social Media Monitoring.

Questions, other thoughts, experiences? Please feel free to share below.

01.01.2010 Sanjay, learning, social media, social media monitoring View Comments

Facebook’s the New Email: It’s all about Reach

by sanjay on Thursday, December 31st, 2009

Time was when companies would accumulate large email lists so they could write to these people, updating them about their offerings and promotions. In fact, we still come across a lot of companies who think in terms of creating an “email database”.

So for long since the Internet was recognized as a means to reach your prospects, email has lived and thrived. That one great way to have your brand message delivered directly to your prospect, in her email box, which she was certainly going to see. At such a low cost. And which is how, companies and brands started using email a lot.

Till the point of time that email was also discovered by few others: those that wanted to sell you Viagra, those who promised to get you rich quickly, and others that offered to deliver free porn to your desktop! With junk and spam coming into the email system, users got wary, stopped accepting many emails and suddenly, email became a dirty word, for sending out brand messages.

As we meet and talk to clients and prospects, there are many who want to drive traffic to their website and the website alone, even while using our services to generate Social Media engagement. They feel that the website is “theirs” with their brand name etc., and which is where the traffic should be ultimately driven. And where they can then pick up the email addresses of these visitors!

Well, I think they need to understand a few new realities:

  1. People get just way too much email, and most users filter email and block spam. And there is every chance that your email may not really reach the customer.
  2. People are very concerned about leaving behind their email ids at sites now. So the genuine customers and prospects may not even be in your email list.
  3. This also means that when you drive traffic only to your website, it may be that one-off visit, but you lose the customer thereafter, as she did not leave behind any of her contact details.
  4. It is the new world of convergence, and of using multiple devices to access the Internet. In scenarios like these, what is really important? To have your brand message reach your prospect and get read. Does it matter how that happens?
  5. The other comfort that a mailing list used to give earlier was the possible reuse of that list, to reach the customer again, after a while. Well, on email in fact, people are less tolerant now. I will get into my email box, only that information which I really want to see. Anyone else sending email to me, and that too repeatedly, is taking up my time and attention, and is therefore not welcome!

So what options do brands have now, to deliver their message to their prospects and customers? If not email, then what?

Consider the option of a Facebook Fan page.

You create one for your brand. You populate it with good content. You also put out images and videos there. You are subtle in your marketing messages. You genuinely show the human face of your brand. You actually converse with your customers. And in doing all these, you pick up “fans”. Those folks on Facebook who tell you that ‘they like what you are putting up out there, and will not mind your occasional updates coming on to their Facebook walls’.

Permission marketing, anyone?

Why is this working at this time?

Clearly, the nature of the medium teaches brands, and they comply as well, to keep their messages small, simple, friendly and subtle. As against that weapon of the HTML email that marketers had got in their hands, with Flash and what not, and which was blatantly pushy. And which consumers wanted nothing of.

So the simplicity of the Facebook update works well.

Then again, the brand is not expected to push too many updates, too often. As soon as a brand tries to overdo this, for the user who has her Facebook wall full of one brand’s updates, it takes only a click to withdraw her fan-dom for the brand. Email also offered the “unsubscribe” option in such cases, but too often it did not work, and it was also in the hands of the sender of the email, to stop sending those emails to you. In case of Facebook, the control is in the hands of the user herself. And if any brand still finds a way to abuse the system (say, by pushing “messages”), then big brother Facebook is quick to the rescue of the user.

So getting occasional updates and not too many, is also a good thing.

Facebook fans may become fans of many things. At this time, not many are un-fanning themselves that often. In other words, for a brand, if they acquire say, 10,000 fans, that is nearly as good, or perhaps better than acquiring 10,000 email addresses. With those 10,000 fans, even if you do not know much about them, you are able to reach them with your updates when you have something useful to tell them. They are usually around and don’t leave you. Unlike the email addresses which change every once in a while, a user’s Facebook account is normally not changing that frequently. And the other advantage is the viral aspect. Today, we have gone past the early stage of email usage, where we would forward good emails to long mailing lists of our friends. So an email is perhaps going to reach only that one individual to whom it is sent. On the other hand, a good Facebook update like a video is easily “shared”, and suddenly you get a possible viral surge on your fans list.

I have told many of our clients that they should not be obsessed with driving traffic to their website. Their Facebook page is as much “theirs” as their website. If they drive traffic to the website, but the user does not leave behind an email address, there will still be an effort to reach him the next time. On the other hand, if you drive traffic to a good Facebook page and manage to get the user to click a simple button and become your fan, you have reach to him for a long time.

So as long as Facebook rules ensure that companies remain disciplined on this front, till then, Facebook’s your new email! That one way to get to your prospects and customers, in a permission marketing mode.

And what about Twitter then? Is having Twitter followers also the same thing? I guess not. To penetrate a user’s mindshare on Twitter, amidst tons of tweets flowing past him continuously, takes more than getting the person to just follow you. With filtering concepts like groups and lists emerging, the user will have to pick your account and put it in a list that he “wants to see” for sure, and then only, does it become the equivalent of the Facebook case.

What do you think? Do you agree that Facebook’s your new email? Any other experiences that you have had? Please share in comments below.

31.12.2009 Sanjay, campaign, facebook, social media View Comments

Previous Entries